Edited Apr. 19 at 12:09 p.m.
Quoting: IconicHawk
Also the reason why the coyotes didn’t relocate to Quebec was simple: Detroit and Columbus would rather fold then move west again
Quoting: aadoyle
I think Quebec should be saved for expansion rather then just relocation. Kind of like Houston
But first get a team in Saskatchewan so we can fill in the map lul
Quoting: A_Habs_fan
Like the Thrashers before them, ownership failed to Yotes and now the team will move. Meruelo was a problem, he should not get a 2nd chance at a team, Arizona should though, like Atlanta, they have the fans and metro area to have a successful team, it will depends on ownership and a good arena but they can be a good spot
I'm starting to suspect that the NHL used the post-expansion buzz from Seattle/Vegas to float the idea of being "open to expansion" for the sole purpose of building a market around finding a relocation option for the Coyotes because they were "stuck" with the Meruelo/Mullett situation. They approved him as an owner, approved the arena situation, then got burned when Tempe vote failed.
All of the "expansion" talk from Utah, Houston, Atlanta, Cincinnati, and Omaha were based on Commissioner Bettman doing his job by trying to build a market through "soft conversations" with potential NHL owners (a pretty small group of likely candidates/markets to be sure) through signaling that they would entertain any "expression of interest".
The NHL could have been as pissed off as they wanted about the Coyotes situation but without a legitimate long-term alternative they would just be kicking the can down the road. And I also think that the owners would never give too much authority to Bettman to simply "revoke" an owner from his team without a major Show Cause type of event; which they didn't have on Meruelo.
Houston - didn't appear to be in play based on Fertitta balking at the purchase price of around a Billion USD$; he wants to buy cheap sell high and without him there is no viable Houston option because he has the arena operating rights thru 2033.
Atlanta - has 2 bidders for expansion but their timelines are at least 3 years away at the earliest.
All of that was simply leverage to get someone like Ryan Smith to step up his offer to the range they needed and the timeline they needed to force Meruelo to sell under the conditions they needed and avoid a legal fight.
Now that this has occurred, the NHL will wait to call Meruelo's bluff on the 5 year "right of first refusal" that he has to bring NHL back to Phoenix area. If he does not then I would be surprised if the NHL pursued expansion again. If he does they would have to consider the impact of expanding with two teams (Atlanta/Phoenix for example) and the disruption that would have to NHL teams.
In any case, having multiple cities/ownership groups interested in the NHL is a good thing since the NHL's job is to create value for its owners.
The catch-22 for Bettman, is that when there is too much unmet demand for franchises that is when competitor leagues start to form and I wonder about something like that popping up with Atlanta, Houston, Quebec, Hamilton, Phoenix (if NHL doesn't return), Cincinnati, Kansas City all feeling like they can host high-level pro hockey along with a team like the Chicago Wolves and other "major league cities" such as Cleveland, Milwaukee, San Francisco, Portland, San Diego, Charlotte, Orlando, Jacksonville, New Orleans, Oklahoma City, San Antonio, Memphis, Indianapolis, Baltimore, and even Brooklyn. Could be another WHA/IHL type of situation.
If I were one of those potential primary owners I think I would target the CBA expiration as an option to start with a 6-8 team independent league in "hockey-starved" cities that the NHL doesn't serve.
And there should be no debate: there is no way a league can threaten the NHL like the WHA did; but there could be some impacts to the AHL/NCAA/CHL as they all stand in uncertainty regarding player issues and it could be something like the IHL was.
I also feel that there is a large unmet demand from both fans/players in Europe to have an "AHL equivalent" that if a league had 6-8 teams on both continents it could be viable financially as a replacement for the KHL/AHL for NHL fringe players.