Yeah this ain't it.

I disagree with almost all of these

How

Why not

Not a single one of those in the 3rd first lines is overrated, for example.

Had to take someone from each team

To understand who is overrated, one must know the definition of overrated.

There's a difference between an overrated player and the best/most valuable player of the entire team

This seems more like a thread designed to bait people into arguing with you.

Barkov, Draisaitl, Kane a bit if you want.
All RD, agreed and except Vasilevskiy, agreed for G. Otherwise, not sure why you think they're overrated.

Between this roster and your "most underrated" roster, which team should you bet on in a head-to-head 7 game series?

literally everybody talks $hit about Ristolainen, how is he over rated LMAO

Silfverberg > Kapanen, so how is he over-rated?

I actually think Barkov is underrated. If he played in a bigger market, he'd a superstar in this league.

That's a good list.

Lmao not at all

If everyone talks about how underrated you are, youre not underrated.

I agree with most of them, but I question Ziba, he is a fine 1C, ig I've seen a few Rangers fans say he's a top 5-10 C in the league, but IMO that's not enough to be considered one of the most overrated players in the league
Silf is a fine middle 6 guy, I don't think people really view him as more than that
Pesce-I mean he did have a down year this year, and people don't want to admit that, yes, but he was legitimately elite for at least last year
Dumo is one of the least talked about players on the pens, and is (quite easily) the most valuable player on that defense, he's the guy that covers for Letang, is the best defender on the team, and he easily holds his own on the top pair
I'd also go Ryan Johansen for NSH, but tbh I don't know much about Arvidsson, so I could easily be swayed

Klefbom under

WHAT?? How is this list overrated? Draisaitl, Barkov, Connor, Pastrnak, Klefbom, Jones, Burns, Vasilevsky etc.. the list goes on of how many of these players are not overrated.. it looks like all your doing is putting on a lot of the good players.

guess it depends on what your definition of underrated is. If everyone said McDavid sucked does that mean he sucks? No, not at all.

Over the last 3 years he is 7th in point among centers and ahead of guys like JT, Matthews and Eichel. If you wanted to look at it from a P/GP view he's right there with Matthews/Eichel and better than JT. On top of that he's been fantastic in the face-off circle (equal to Matthews, slightly worse than JT and better than Eichel) and finished top 5 in Selke voting the 2 previous seasons (none of the other 3 have). He's only 24yr old which is all of 2 years older than Matthews and a year older than Eichel. No one talks about Barkov as a franchise player like they do Matthew or Eichel. Again if this guy played in a bigger market he would be an absolute superstar in this league.

Maybe 5 guys on here I could agree with but the majority are legit players far from being overrated.

Without going into too much detail, you basically put really good players who are fairly rated as really good or formerly good players that had a down year and people are recognizing this dip in effectiveness. Both mean they aren't overrated

how is klef overated