Quoting: A_Habs_fan
That comment is wrong on so many levels, if the league commits medical malpractice it should be called out, no matter who says it, as fans, we SHOULD want the league to be a nice and clean one on all levels, from the Commissioner to the assistant coaches and equipment guys. Lehner is setting a great example here about standing up for the right reasons instead of not doing anything about a bad situation.
Quoting: yikes
I’m gonna keep it civil and I do get what you’re sayin; but the job of the NHLpa Isn’t to satisfy fans or the NHL. Their job is to protect the players. Not as athletes or investments but as individuals that work for the NHL. Lehner calling out issues that have proof and sources is a bother to the NHL. But is it wrong to be a bother? Just cause what Lehner says may be annoying or “tainting our precious league that we all value as fans” isn’t a bad thing. Sure you may dislike it but to have a voice standing up for players Health (mental and physical) is firstly; More important than staying quiet
And secondly quite literally what you’d want from the NHLPA
NHLPA is not supposed to be our friends as fans, and Lehner doesn’t need to be a friend to anyone. What he says isn’t pipe dreams. If they were I’d understand you more; but what he’s saying seemingly has legitimate facts/ sources.
I respect your opinion but I can also say that you’re just wrong. There is merit to what Lehner is saying and he’s not the first guy, and he’s definitely not gonna be the last. Lehner has views that I don’t agree and some that I do. Regardless; these recent “stories” aren’t supposed to be fun to read or be good for the game. He’s trying to make the game better by showing the flaws and hoping to improve on them.
Quoting: Kotkaniemi15
So you’re saying that it’s a good thing that the NHL fined the Rangers?
It isn’t a bad thing for people like the Rangers, Tortorella, and Lehner to put forth valid criticisms of egregious problems that need to be fixed. If no one can ever question the system, then it’s never going to change for the better.
And if the thing that you won’t forgive has anything to do with his political leaning, everything he’s spoken out about has certainly proven he doesn’t support/follow the harmful ideas others of the same leaning often stand for.
Wow, looks like I started a war single-handedly. Feel like Rhett Butler standing in a room full of Confederates telling them the Yankees are better equipped to win the war and then having them all tear him to shreds (if you got that reference, you're a legend).
1) Now, to be clear: My point (as to what
@A_Habs_fan alluded to) is not that speaking out about medical malpractice that doesn't involve the speaker personally is wrong. My point is that Lehner should chime in only if the actual player involved in the incident (in this case, Patrick) supports him. Perhaps he does, but I haven't seen any indication of that yet. If Patrick does feel a grievance towards the Flyers for this, then Lehner is right, and I'm wrong. Either way however, he should not have mentioned Vigneault by name.
2) As to what
@yikes said about not objecting to the league being "tainted"-I don't object to it at all. I do object to Lehner calling out coaches
by name. He shouldn't be doing that, regardless of his stance on the Flyers alleged medical malpractice.
3) Lastly,
@Kotkaniemi15, I was astounded that Wilson was let off the hook for bashing Buchnevich's cranium into the ice and rag-dolling Panarin afterwards, but the Rangers shouldn't have called out the head of the player safety department by name. A better way of saying it would be "We are severely disappointed with the league's decision" or some other vague, non-specific announcement, but you can't call out the guy in charge of the department by name, criticize him as not actually caring for the safety of players, and expect to NOT be fined (and again, I was on the Rangers' side all the way through). If Lehner had just called out the Flyers alone, that would be one thing, but don't bash Alain Vigneault on Twitter when you're a player. It comes off as very showy and obnoxious.
In short, I agree that Lehner raising awareness about mental health is good, that if he is supported by Patrick in this that his comments are just and that he has the right to say what he wants; I also agree that the league should be clean regardless of who raises the issue. I especially agree with the statement of Kotkaniemi15 "If no one can ever question the system, then it’s never going to change for the better." I don't agree that he would make a good NHLPA rep if he's calling out people by name, nor do I agree that he should be saying this IF Nolan Patrick is not (but again, if Patrick supports his coming forward with this, then I'm simply wrong).